Pricing
How to reprice when ingredient costs go up: what to change when flour rises 20 percent
When flour rises 20 percent, a plain loaf's cost rises about 6 percent and a decorated cake's barely moves. How to find affected products and reprice where it matters.
the ibakepro team ·
When flour goes up 20 percent, a plain loaf's total cost rises about 6 percent and a decorated cake's about a quarter of one percent, so raise the loaf and leave the cake alone. Find every product the ingredient is in, work out how much of each product's total cost it really is, reprice only where the required move is bigger than the smallest price step you would publish, and tell customers once, with a date.
Putting 5 percent on everything is the one answer guaranteed to be wrong on every product you sell, because a 20 percent rise on one ingredient never becomes a 20 percent rise on anything you make.
Step 1: find every product the ingredient is actually in
You will write the obvious list from memory, and it will be short. The ones you miss are where the ingredient sits a layer down: flour is in the sponge, and the sponge is in the tiered cake, the cake pops, the crumb topping and the trifle. It is in the roux in a savoury filling.
Do it in two passes, in this order.
- Every recipe or sub-recipe that names the ingredient directly.
- Every product that uses any of those recipes, at any depth.
The second pass is the one that catches people, and nobody does it reliably from memory past about a dozen products. If your recipes nest, the ingredient's footprint is everything downstream of it, not everything you can picture.
Step 2: the rise on the invoice is not the rise on the product
Three things sit between the supplier's percentage and yours.
The ingredient is a share of your raw materials, not all of them. If flour is 40 percent of what a loaf costs in materials, a 20 percent rise on flour is an 8 percent rise in that loaf's materials. If flour is 4 percent of a decorated cake's materials, the same rise moves that cake by 0.8 percent.
Raw materials are a share of your total cost, not all of it. Labour, overhead and your per-order fixed costs did not move because the flour did. On a labour-heavy product they are most of the cost, which is why a decorated cake barely notices an ingredient shock and a plain loaf feels all of it.
Overhead amplifies, if you allocate it as a percentage. If overhead is a percentage of materials plus labour, one unit of extra materials becomes one unit plus the overhead charged on it. At a 15 percent overhead rate, every unit of extra ingredient cost is 1.15 units of extra total cost.
Here it is on two products, indexed so raw materials equal 100, overhead at 15 percent of materials plus labour, each carrying 10 as its share of fixed monthly costs. The gap between the two columns is the point. If you have not broken a product down into those four lines before, the cake pricing calculator walks through building one.
| Plain loaf | Decorated cake | |
|---|---|---|
| Raw materials | 100 (flour is 40 of it) | 100 (flour is 4 of it) |
| Labour | 25 | 200 |
| Overhead at 15% | 18.75 | 45.00 |
| Fixed cost share | 10 | 10 |
| Total cost | 153.75 | 355.00 |
| Cost after flour +20% | 162.95 | 355.92 |
| Cost increase | +5.98% | +0.26% |
The same invoice needs a 6 percent move on one product and a quarter of a percent on the other.
Step 3: why a flat percentage is the wrong answer
Put 6 percent on everything and you have overcharged the decorated cake by roughly twenty times its actual increase, on the products customers scrutinise hardest. Put 2 percent on everything and the loaf, where the increase actually landed, covers about a third of it: you have cut the margin on your highest-volume line and raised it on the ones that did not need it.
A third failure is easy to miss. If your sizes are priced on a deliberate ladder, a flat percentage on each rung produces prices nobody would publish, so you round them, and the rounding is where the ladder breaks. Reprice a ladder as a ladder: fix the base rung on the arithmetic, then rebuild the rungs above it.
Step 4: reprice, or absorb, deliberately
Hold your price and the increase comes out of your margin. The size of the hit is easy to compute.
Margin points lost = cost increase divided by current price.
The loaf above, at a 40 percent margin, sells for 256.25 against its 153.75 cost. The 9.20 increase divided by 256.25 is 3.6, so its margin falls from 40 percent to 36.4 percent. The cake loses 0.16 of a point, which rounds away to nothing.
To hold the margin instead, the price must move by more than the cost did in absolute terms, because your margin sits on top of the increase too.
New price = new cost divided by (1 minus your target margin).
At a 40 percent target, every unit of extra cost needs 1.67 units of extra price. The percentage rise in price matches the percentage rise in cost, but the amount does not. Add exactly the cost increase to the price and you have absorbed the margin on it while telling yourself you repriced.
Four rules that make the decision quick:
- Reprice when the required move is bigger than the smallest step you would publish. If the arithmetic says 0.26 percent and your prices move in steps of a couple of percent, repricing is noise. Absorb it and note the date.
- Absorb only with a date attached. An absorbed increase nobody revisits is a permanent margin cut that no one ever decided to make.
- A single product can justify its own price change. If the ingredient is a large share of one product and that product is a large share of your volume, move that one and leave the rest alone.
- Below cost is not a repricing problem. If a product already sold for under what it costs to make, the increase is not the thing that needs fixing.
A useful floor while you are in there: at or above target is fine, below target but above half of it is worth watching, below half your target means the work is barely paying for itself and below cost means every sale loses money and volume makes it worse.
Step 5: the backlog you have already sold
Orders you accepted last month are priced at last month's price and will be baked at this month's cost. That gap is real cash, it is bounded and you can size it in five minutes: accepted-but-unbaked orders multiplied by the per-order increase.
Your margin report will not show it if your system records each order's cost when the order was taken, so expect the backlog to look better on paper than it is until it clears.
Set a changeover date and be specific: quotes issued before it hold the old price to their stated expiry, quotes issued after it carry the new one. Then honour that exactly, including the ones you would rather not.
Step 6: telling customers
- Change on a date, not gradually. A drifting price looks like something you hope nobody notices.
- Say it once, in one or two sentences. No apology and no essay about the supply chain. A long explanation reads as an opening bid and invites negotiation.
- Never itemise your costs to a customer. It turns your price into a debate about your suppliers, which you cannot win and should not be having.
- Tell standing-order and wholesale customers first, individually. They are on an agreement in spirit even when nothing is in writing, and finding out from a shelf label is how those relationships end.
A message you can copy, for customers:
From 1 November, our sourdough loaf will be $9.50 and our 8 inch celebration cakes will start at $165. Orders and quotes confirmed before then keep their current price. Thank you for baking with us.
And for wholesale and standing-order customers, sent individually two to four weeks ahead:
Hi Sam, a heads-up before it appears on your invoice: from 1 November your sourdough price moves from $5.20 to $5.60 a loaf. Everything else on your standing order stays the same. Happy to talk it through if useful.
Then measure what actually happened, because the fear beforehand and the outcome afterwards are rarely the same size, and only one of them gets written down. Three things make that measurement reliable.
Count units, not revenue. Revenue rises on its own when the price does, so revenue will tell you the change went well even in the weeks you were losing customers. Units sold is the only figure that answers the question you asked.
Compare like weeks, over several of them. The same weekday against the same weekday, for at least three or four weeks. A single quiet week after a price change proves nothing about the price, and the week immediately after is the least representative one you will get.
Watch the products you did not move. They are your control. If the lines you repriced and the lines you left alone both fell by about the same amount, you are looking at a slow month, not a reaction to your price. If only the repriced ones fell, you have learned something real.
Write the date of the change next to the numbers. A price change with no date attached turns into a permanent, unresolvable argument about whether it worked.
Before the next invoice arrives
- Which three ingredients are the largest share of your materials spend? Those are the only ones whose price you need to watch weekly.
- For your top five products by volume, what percentage of total cost is raw materials? That tells you in advance how exposed each one is.
- What is the smallest price step you would ever publish? Anything below it is not a repricing decision.
Write those three answers down once. Together they turn the next invoice from an afternoon of arithmetic into a five-minute check.
Software helps most with step one. When you change an ingredient price in ibakepro, it recosts every product that uses it, including through components such as a sponge or a dough, and flags each one whose margin has drifted off target, with the price that would restore it, while leaving your published price unchanged until you apply a new one. Why ibakepro will not change your prices for you explains that choice.